• NO.1 Charlotte Tilbury Eyes to Mesmerise
  • NO.2 M·A·C Pro Longwear Paint Pot
  • NO.3 IT COSMETICS Naturally Pretty Essentials™ Matte Luxe Transforming Eyeshadow Palette
  • NO.4 CLINIQUE All About Shadow™ Quad
  • NO.5 MAYBELLINE EyeStudio ColorTattoo 24HR Eyeshadow
  • NO.6 BOBBI BROWN Long-Wear Cream Eyeshadow Stick
  • NO.7 RMS Beauty Eye Polish
  • NO.8 Xtreme Lashes Glideshadow Long Lasting Eyeshadow Stick
  • NO.9 Clé de Peau Beauté Eye Color Quad
  • NO.10 Jillian Dempsey Lid Tint

10 Best Cream Eyeshadows for Mature Eyes 2022

Mar 18, 2022

When it comes to the best eyeshadows for mature eyes, I would definitely recommend cream eyeshadows over powder eyeshadows, because they are easier to blend and less likely to cause creasing or settle into lines. Cream eyeshadow, in particular, can be extremely beneficial to those with dry eye area. To fix dry issue, you can choose an eyeshadow with hydrating formula as well. If you have mature eyes, it is recommended to use matte eyeshadow that won’t accentuate fine lines. Avoid applying too much eyeshadow can help you create a fresh look. And keep in mind that neutral colors like light pink, gray tend to look great on you.

To help you find a great eyeshadow for mature eyes, I rounded up the 10 best cream eyeshadow for mature eyes to meet your various need. Some are long-lasting, some are nourishing, some are for sensitive eyes. Scroll on to find your dream eyeshadow.

View More
  • Easy to blend
  • Water-infused cream
  • Easy glide-on formula
  • Antioxidant protection
  • None

Founded in 2013, Charlotte Tilbury is a namesake brand of British makeup artist Charlotte Tilbury. The mission of Charlotte Tilbury is to empower everyone in the world to be the most beautiful version of themselves. This eyes to mesmerize is specially designed for mature eyes, aiming to create a youthful-looking, fresh eye look. With easy glide-on formula, its water-infused cream eyeshadow is easy to blend, and it includes Vitamin E that can hydrate and provide antioxidant protection. The best part is that this cream eyeshadow has a cooling, soothing formula to take care of delicate eye area. Available in multiple colors, it can help create a flattering look and make your eyes pop.

Here is one of its reviews:” It's very smooth and soft to the touch, like chocolate moose! It appears to be delicious. It's very easy to apply, and I didn't realize how shimmery and glittery it was until I applied it. I loooove it!”

View More


  • Lasts for 24 hours
  • Blend smoothly
  • Highly pigmented
  • Buildable
  • Powerful primer
  • None

Founded in 194, MAC has sold its product in over 120 countries. The mission of MAC is to enable limitless self-expression by turning makeup into art for all customers. This pro longwear paint pot from MAC can work as a great eye primer or long-lasting cream eyeshadow. Its creamy texture is easy to blend for mature eyes without settling into fine lines. As a highly pigmented eyeshade, the buildable pro longwear paint pot can be worn alone to create a vibrant finish that can last 24 hours. This eyeshadow is suitable for those seeking long-lasting eye makeup with mature eyes, and it is a cost-effective choice for those without an eye primer.

One customer loved how powerful it works as a primer:” As a primer for powder eye shadow, I use the Pro Longwear Paint Pot. It's a great primer! It keeps the color fresh and in place throughout the day. I could definitely wear it alone, but as a primer, it is unbeatable. ”

View More
  • Travel-friendly
  • Anti-aging shadows
  • Infused with hydrolyzed collagen
  • Can be used as eyeliner
  • Colors fade over hour

Founded in 2008, IT Cosmetics uses skin-loving ingredients in its makeup or skincare product to nourish all skin types. IT Cosmetics is committed to empowering customers to feel more confident. This mini-size eyeshadow is travel-friendly and can be worn as eyeshadow or eyeliner. The naturally pretty essentials palette includes six matte anti-aging shadows and one magic Transforming Hello Light™ shade, and you can tap it onto a matte shade and turn it into gorgeous satin. To nourish eye area of mature eyes, the shadow is infused with hydrolyzed collagen, real silk, peptides and proprietary No-Tug Technology™ for extra care. The drawback is that this eyeshadow is not long-lasting, and may fade after hours.

One customer said that this eyeshadow can create a unique natural look:” It applies smoothly, and it gives sufficient coverage. The color is very natural and produces a look that I can't achieve with any other product.”

View More
  • Crease-resistant
  • Fade-resistant
  • For sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers
  • Not for those who have carmine allergy

Founded in 1968, Clinique insists on using safe ingredients on its product. To help build health skin, now all products from Clinique are free from parabens, phthalates, and fragrance. This All About Shadow™ Quad is crease-resistant and fade-resistant, which is why it is ideal for mature eyes. Tested by ophthalmologists, this eyeshadow can be worn by sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers. Easy to apply and blend, the eyeshadow comes with two sponge-tip applicators. Note this product isn’t for those who have carmine allergy.

View More
  • Intense color
  • Long-lasting
  • Fade-proof
  • Crease-free
  • Multiple colors
  • None

Founded in Chicago in 1914, Maybelline New York aims to offer innovative, accessible, effortless cosmetics for every woman. This EyeStudio ColorTattoo 24HR Eyeshadow can hold up to 24-hour wear without creasing or fading, and this highly pigmented eyeshadow can offer intense color. Available in 17 colors, you can use a classic shade for an elegant look, or use a bold shade for impressive smokey eyes. The unique cream-gel texture is easy to blend on mature eyes, delivering a coveted finish effortlessly. This eyeshadow is ideal for those looking for a long-lasting look.

Here is one of its reviews:” Bad to the Bronze is a nice metallic that isn't overly reflective or glittery, making it appropriate for a wide range of ages. Even without primer, it lasts a long time on my normal/combo skin. I wore it overnight to see how it held up, and the next day it was barely worn, with no creasing at all.”

View More
  • Long-wearing
  • Just swipe and go
  • Cruelty-free
  • Water-resistant
  • Easy to apply
  • Doesn't go well with any other shadows

If you are looking for a quick and easy eyeshadow, don’t miss this long-wear cream eyeshadow stick from Bobbi Brown. Bobbi Brown, an eponymous brand of American professional makeup artist Bobbi Brown, has offered universally flattering products with unparalleled quality. This long-wearing eyeshadow stick is so easy to apply that you can finish your eye look in seconds, which makes it perfect for busy mothers. The water-resistant eyeshadow stick is free of parabens, formaldehydes, phthalates, and it is cruelty-free as well. Available in matte finish and shimmer finish, the eyeshadow stick can be used to creating effortlessly beautiful looks. Note this product might not go well with other shadows.

Here is one of its reviews:” This shadow stick can be used to define, shade, and smoke up the eyes. It can hold up to 8 hours without creasing. It is also watertight!!! This shade stick enhanced and highlighted my eyes. I strongly recommend it.”

View More


RMS Beauty
Most Nourishing Eyeshadow
  • Naturally derived pigments
  • Natural oil base
  • Soothing effect
  • For dry or aging eyes
  • Not long-lasting

RMS beauty is founded by Rose-Marie Swift, a prominent global makeup artist. The mission of RMS beauty is to support natural beauty and long-term health of customers. This eye polish eyeshadow is made from naturally derived pigments and natural oil base that has a soothing effect, which makes it an ideal choice for dry or mature eyes. The nourishing cream is easy to blend, providing a flattering, radiant look. The drawback is that this eye polish is not long-lasting and might fade over hours.

View More
  • No powdery fall out
  • 5-in-1
  • Hypoallergenic
  • Highly pigmented
  • Paraben Free
  • None

Founded in 2005, Xtreme Lashes is known for as one of the most trusted brands in semi-permanent eyelash extensions. This glideshadow long-lasting 5-in-1 eyeshadow stick can be used as eyeshadow, eyeliner, base, highlight and contour. This highly pigmented eyeshadow stick can create perfect smoky eyes without fallout or kickback. Free of paraben, sulfate, gluten and fragrance, the hypoallergenic eyeshadow stick is healthy for skin. This eyeshadow is ideal for smoky eye lovers with mature eyes.

View More
  • Advanced moisturizing ingredient
  • Contains Argan Oil
  • Smooth
  • A little pricey

Founded in Japan in 1982, clé de peau beauté aims to push the boundaries of skin cell science and maximize skin’s natural radiance. clé de peau beauté is committed to discovering new ingredients to nourish and enhance skin. Featuring Hydro-Wrap Complex EX, an advanced moisturizing ingredient of clé de peau beauté, this eye color quad can nourish and hydrate delicate eye area. With Argan oil, this eyeshadow is smooth and easy to blend. Full of nutrition, the eyeshadow is perfect for mature eyes to create an elegant everyday look. The drawback is that it is more expensive than other eyeshadows.

View More
  • Organic ingredients
  • Easy to blend
  • For natural look
  • Cruelty-free
  • None

Jillian Dempsey is dedicated to helping customers reveal their most authentic and astonishing selves. This cruelty-free lid tint is made from organic ingredients, free of harmful chemicals. Easy to blend, this product is designed to create a fresh and natural look. Available in matte and shimmer finish, this foolproof eyeshadow can make your eyes pop, and its natural colors look great with mature eyes. If you want to create a subtle look, don’t miss this eyeshadow.

View More




Please review our Cookie Policy for more information. By clicking "Accept" you agree to our "Cookie Policy". Accept

Sign Up

Aleady a account ?

By continuing, you agree to GuideMaser's Terms of Service, Privacy Policy and Cookie use.

Confirm Email Address

GuideMaser sent a confirmation email to: [email protected]
Click the Confirm link in the email to secure your GuideMaser account.


Send a password reset email

We sent a message to so you can pick your new password.

Pick a new password


Create Account


Change Password